North Yorkshire: housing land supply, local plan and appeals

North Yorkshire Council says it can show a 2.26-year supply of housing land, at 1 April 2026, measured against Five-year requirement of 20,569 homes (5% buffer) for the whole area, built from an annual requirement per former district; Hambleton is measured against its adopted Local Plan target because that plan is under five years old, the other six against local housing need, short of the five years national policy asks for.

The ten most recent appeal decisions that dealt with land supply, from 22 July 2026 to 12 November 2026, all found the council could not show five years. Before that, inspectors found it could, most recently on 20 May 2026.

It scored 218% in the 2025 Housing Delivery Test, with no consequence listed.

Its local plan, the Craven Local Plan 2012-2032, was adopted on 12 November 2025. A replacement, the North Yorkshire Local Plan, is at the scoping consultation.

Updated 2026-11-17 (2 days ago). Every figure links to where it comes from.

Five-year housing land supply

North Yorkshire Council's latest published position is a 2.26-year supply of deliverable housing land for the period 2026/27 to 2030/31, made up of 9,313 homes it expects on deliverable sites. It is measured against Five-year requirement of 20,569 homes (5% buffer) for the whole area, built from an annual requirement per former district; Hambleton is measured against its adopted Local Plan target because that plan is under five years old, the other six against local housing need.

Other councils in the Yorkshire and the Humber

Each council's own latest figure; base dates differ. All councils are on the land supply map of England.

Source: the council's land supply statement, published October 2026. Checked 2026-11-02 (2 weeks ago).

What inspectors found at appeal

A council's own land supply figure is often tested at appeal. These are the most recent appeal decisions in North Yorkshire where the inspector dealt with land supply, and what each one found.

  1. Five years not shownNot disputed12 November 2026 - appeal allowed
    Land north of Hill Foot Lane, Burn Bridge, Harrogate
    “where, as in this case, the Council is unable to demonstrate a 5-year supply of deliverable housing sites.”
    Figures given: inspector 2.2 years. Decision 6009661
  2. Five years not shownNot disputed3 November 2026 - appeal allowed
    Land to the rear of Plinthstones, School Road, Hemingbrough
    “It is common ground that as the Council can only demonstrate a 2.4 year housing land supply, the proposal would be for development which would address "an evidenced unmet need"”
    Figures given: council 2.4 years. Decision 6008696
  3. Five years not shownNot disputed7 October 2026 - appeal dismissed
    22 Coppice Avenue, Harrogate
    “I afford substantial weight to the provision of a home in the context of the Council not being able to demonstrate a 5-year deliverable supply of housing sites”
    Figures given: council 2.2 years. Decision 6012375
  4. Five years not shownNot disputed30 September 2026 - appeal dismissed
    Balne Moor Coarse Fishery, Balne Moor Road, Balne
    “only 2.6 years' worth of housing land supply can be demonstrated”
    Figures given: inspector 2.6 years. Decision 6010112
  5. Five years not shownNot disputed18 September 2026 - appeal dismissed
    Barn on West Lane, Galphay, Ripon, North Yorkshire
    “Whilst the Council cannot demonstrate a five-year supply of deliverable housing sites”
  6. Five years not shownNot disputed17 August 2026 - appeal dismissed
    Wharfedale Cottage, Church Fenton Road, Ulleskelf
    “The Council has confirmed that it cannot demonstrate a 5-year housing land supply”
  7. Five years not shownNot disputed30 July 2026 - appeal dismissed
    Chapel Field, Marton cum Grafton
    “As the Council is unable to demonstrate a five-year supply of housing land, paragraph 11d) of the Framework is engaged”
  8. Five years not shownDisputed29 July 2026 - appeal dismissed
    Land Comprising Field At 425020 467745, Low Gate Lane, Sawley, North Yorkshire
    “However, the Council can only demonstrate 2.2 years housing land supply, well short of the 5 years required.”
    Figures given: council 2.2 years. Decision 6006155

Showing the 8 most recent of 58 decisions in North Yorkshire that dealt with land supply. Planther searches and reads all of them for a site.

Housing Delivery Test

The Housing Delivery Test compares the homes built in a council's area over three years with the number needed. North Yorkshire scored 218% in the 2025 measurement, published on 17 August 2026. The consequence listed in the government's results is: None.

YearHomes neededHomes delivered
2022 to 20231,4223,314
2023 to 20241,3883,085
2024 to 20251,3612,706

Source: Housing Delivery Test 2025 measurement. Every council's result: Housing Delivery Test results.

Local plan

The development plan is the Craven Local Plan 2012-2032, Hambleton Local Plan 2014-2036, Harrogate District Local Plan 2014-2035, Harrogate New Settlement (Maltkiln) Development Plan Document, Richmondshire Local Plan 2012-2028 Core Strategy plus saved Richmondshire Local Plan 1999-2006 policies, Ryedale Plan - Local Plan Strategy and Local Plan Sites Document, Helmsley Plan, Scarborough Borough Local Plan 2011-2032, Whitby Business Park Area Action Plan, Selby District Core Strategy Local Plan 2011-2027 plus saved Selby District Local Plan 2005 policies, Yorkshire and Humber Plan York Green Belt policies YH9 and Y1, Minerals and Waste Joint Plan 2015-2030 and Made neighbourhood plans, adopted on 12 November 2025.

Twelve made neighbourhood plans; Knaresborough and Terrington are at examination and six more have been submitted.

The North Yorkshire Local Plan

Being prepared under the plan-making system introduced in 2026, which runs each plan through three gateways in about 30 months.

Now at scoping consultation, step 2 of 9.

  1. Notice of intention16 Oct 2026
  2. NowScoping consultation26 Oct 2026
  3. Gateway 130 Apr 2027
  4. Content and evidence consultation3 Sep 2027
  5. Gateway 25 May 2028
  6. Plan consultation29 Sep 2028
  7. Gateway 316 Feb 2029
  8. Examination30 Mar 2029
  9. Adoption
  1. Notice of intention16 Oct 2026
  2. Scoping consultationNow26 Oct 2026
  3. Gateway 130 Apr 2027
  4. Content and evidence consultation3 Sep 2027
  5. Gateway 25 May 2028
  6. Plan consultation29 Sep 2028
  7. Gateway 316 Feb 2029
  8. Examination30 Mar 2029
  9. Adoption

Dates from the council's published timetable, its local development scheme.

Source: the council's local plan pages. Checked 2026-11-02 (2 weeks ago). Every council: where each local plan has got to.

Planning appeals

Since 2016, inspectors have decided 2,204 appeals against North Yorkshire's decisions and allowed 683 of them (31%), against 31% across all councils. For major schemes, 48 of 103 were allowed (47%, against 50% across all councils).

YearDecidedAllowedShare allowed
201922156 (25%)
202019553 (27%)
202121163 (30%)
202221382 (38%)
202320562 (30%)
202418968 (36%)
202521372 (34%)
202615541 (26%)

Decided means allowed, dismissed or split, with a decision date; a split decision counts as decided but not allowed. From the Planning Inspectorate's published decisions.

North Yorkshire's own pages

Land supply around North Yorkshire

Amber Valley: 5.8 yearsAshfield: 3.86 yearsBabergh: 4.68 yearsBarnsley: 2.9 yearsBassetlaw: 5.31 yearsBedford: 3.35 yearsBirmingham: 6.45 yearsBlaby: 2.78 yearsBlackburn with Darwen: 5.7 yearsBlackpool: 2.1 yearsBolsover: 4.82 yearsBolton: 3.61 yearsBoston: 4.8 yearsBradford: 3.59 yearsBraintree: 5.32 yearsBreckland: 2.88 yearsBroadland: 4.37 yearsBromsgrove: 2.24 yearsBroxtowe: No current figure publishedBuckinghamshire: 0.86 yearsBurnley: 12.3 yearsBury: 4.3 yearsCalderdale: 3.89 yearsCambridge: 2.75 yearsCannock Chase: 5 yearsCentral Bedfordshire: 3.93 yearsCharnwood: 3.56 yearsChelmsford: 4.74 yearsCheltenham: 3.12 yearsCherwell: 3.1 yearsCheshire East: 3.3 yearsCheshire West and Chester: 1.6 yearsChesterfield: 3.46 yearsChorley: 3.4 yearsColchester: 5.05 yearsCotswold: 1.8 yearsCounty Durham: 3.92 yearsCoventry: No current figure publishedCumberland: 2.5 yearsDacorum: 1.2 yearsDarlington: 5.4 yearsDerby: 2.39 yearsDerbyshire Dales: No current figure publishedDoncaster: 6.35 yearsDudley: No current figure publishedEast Cambridgeshire: 6.02 yearsEast Hertfordshire: 3.55 yearsEast Lindsey: 2.33 yearsEast Riding of Yorkshire: No current figure publishedEast Staffordshire: 5.06 yearsEast Suffolk: 3.07 yearsEpping Forest: No current figure publishedErewash: 1.6 yearsFenland: 6.6 yearsForest of Dean: No current figure publishedFylde: 4.35 yearsGateshead: 2.61 yearsGedling: 3.73 yearsGloucester: 3.1 yearsGreat Yarmouth: 6.06 yearsHalton: No current figure publishedHarborough: 3.1 yearsHarlow: 4.9 yearsHartlepool: 5 yearsHerefordshire: 2.81 yearsHigh Peak: 2.47 yearsHinckley and Bosworth: 4.47 yearsHuntingdonshire: 4.28 yearsHyndburn: 5.91 yearsIpswich: 3.46 yearsKing's Lynn and West Norfolk: 6.2 yearsKingston upon Hull: 3.16 yearsKirklees: 4.18 yearsKnowsley: 4.68 yearsLancaster: 2 yearsLeeds: 6.4 yearsLeicester: No current figure publishedLichfield: 3.5 yearsLincoln: 7.1 yearsLiverpool: 5.64 yearsLuton: 4.64 yearsMaldon: 2.8 yearsMalvern Hills: 5.48 yearsManchester: No current figure publishedMansfield: 5.53 yearsMelton: 7.6 yearsMid Suffolk: 6.73 yearsMiddlesbrough: 5.2 yearsMilton Keynes: 5.47 yearsNewark and Sherwood: 4.02 yearsNewcastle-under-Lyme: No current figure publishedNewcastle upon Tyne: No current figure publishedNorth East Derbyshire: 4.47 yearsNorth East Lincolnshire: 3.6 yearsNorth Hertfordshire: 2.43 yearsNorth Kesteven: 7.1 yearsNorth Lincolnshire: No current figure publishedNorth Norfolk: 7.3 yearsNorth Northamptonshire: 4.35 yearsNorth Tyneside: 2.82 yearsNorth Warwickshire: 1.5 yearsNorth West Leicestershire: 5.1 yearsNorth Yorkshire: 2.26 yearsNorthumberland: 7 yearsNorwich: 4.37 yearsNottingham: 6.57 yearsNuneaton and Bedworth: 10.2 yearsOadby and Wigston: 6.68 yearsOldham: 6.7 yearsOxford: 2.88 yearsPendle: 5.32 yearsPeterborough: 4.38 yearsPreston: 5.48 yearsRedcar and Cleveland: 3.62 yearsRedditch: No current figure publishedRibble Valley: 2.24 yearsRochdale: 5.2 yearsRossendale: 5.3 yearsRotherham: 4.4 yearsRugby: 3.4 yearsRushcliffe: 5.1 yearsRutland: 4.34 yearsSalford: 7.1 yearsSandwell: 1.86 yearsSefton: 3.34 yearsSheffield: No current figure publishedShropshire: 4.61 yearsSolihull: No current figure publishedSouth Cambridgeshire: 7.83 yearsSouth Derbyshire: 5.27 yearsSouth Holland: 4.6 yearsSouth Kesteven: 4.07 yearsSouth Norfolk: 4.37 yearsSouth Oxfordshire: 4.46 yearsSouth Ribble: 5.53 yearsSouth Staffordshire: 0.87 yearsSouth Tyneside: Says it cannot show five yearsSt Albans: 1.12 yearsSt Helens: 6.07 yearsStafford: No current figure publishedStaffordshire Moorlands: 2.95 yearsStevenage: 5.59 yearsStockport: 1.77 yearsStockton-on-Tees: 4 yearsStoke-on-Trent: 3.73 yearsStratford-on-Avon: 2.43 yearsStroud: No current figure publishedSunderland: 4.5 yearsTameside: 5.35 yearsTamworth: 1.6 yearsTelford and Wrekin: 6.02 yearsTendring: 3.52 yearsTewkesbury: 3.65 yearsTrafford: 6.6 yearsUttlesford: 5.35 yearsWakefield: 5.5 yearsWalsall: 2 yearsWarrington: 5.14 yearsWarwick: No current figure publishedWelwyn Hatfield: 1.8 yearsWest Lancashire: 2.49 yearsWest Lindsey: 7.1 yearsWest Northamptonshire: No current figure publishedWest Oxfordshire: Says it cannot show five yearsWest Suffolk: 6.02 yearsWestmorland and Furness: 3.17 yearsWigan: 5.45 yearsWirral: 6.63 yearsWolverhampton: Says it cannot show five yearsWorcester: 5.48 yearsWychavon: 5.48 yearsWyre: 8.36 yearsWyre Forest: 8.8 yearsYork: No current figure published
6 years or more5 to 6 years4 to 5 years, or says it cannot show fiveUnder 4 yearsNo current figure published

Each council's own latest figure. The whole country: land supply map of England.

About this page

Planther keeps track of every council's plan, land supply position and appeal record, and rebuilds this page every night from what it holds. Figures are the council's own unless they are marked as an inspector's. If something here is wrong, email hello@planther.co.uk and we will put it right.

See Planther at work in North Yorkshire

Ask Planther about a site and it does the research: the council's position, the appeals that matter, and a first draft, each point with its source. Here it answers a question about North Yorkshire from the figures on this page.

Book a demo

We will show you round Planther, then set you up with a trial so you can try it on your own work. We can usually have you, or your whole firm, up and running the same day.

Bringing a whole firm? We can work to your own contract and data processing agreement, and invoice you directly.