Mole Valley: housing land supply, local plan and appeals

Mole Valley Council says it can show a 5.3-year supply of housing land, at 31 March 2026, measured against Local Plan 2020-2039 requirement of 336 homes a year (1,680 over five years), plus past under-delivery (2,221) and a 20% buffer: 2,665 homes.

The ten most recent appeal decisions that dealt with land supply, from 21 May 2025 to 15 July 2026, all found the council could show five years.

It scored 72% in the 2025 Housing Delivery Test, and the government's results list the presumption in favour of sustainable development as the consequence.

Its local plan, the Mole Valley Local Plan 2020-2039 (2024), was adopted on 15 October 2024.

Updated 2026-11-17 (2 days ago). Every figure links to where it comes from.

Five-year housing land supply

Mole Valley Council's latest published position is a 5.3-year supply of deliverable housing land for the period 2026/27 to 2030/31, made up of 2,816 homes it expects on deliverable sites. It is measured against Local Plan 2020-2039 requirement of 336 homes a year (1,680 over five years), plus past under-delivery (2,221) and a 20% buffer: 2,665 homes.

Other councils in the South East

Each council's own latest figure; base dates differ. All councils are on the land supply map of England.

Source: the council's land supply statement, published 2026-08-13. Checked 2026-11-02 (2 weeks ago).

What inspectors found at appeal

A council's own land supply figure is often tested at appeal. These are the most recent appeal decisions in Mole Valley where the inspector dealt with land supply, and what each one found.

  1. Inspector did not decideNot disputed16 October 2026 - appeal dismissed
    High Bank, Mill Hill Lane, Betchworth
    “The Council advises that it can demonstrate a housing land supply of just over 5 years through the MVLP.”
    Figures given: council 5 years. Decision 6010203
  2. Five years shownDisputed15 July 2026 - appeal dismissed
    thornhill cottage, ifield road, horley, Surrey
    “Accordingly, the Council can demonstrate a five-year supply of deliverable housing sites with the appropriate buffer.”
    Figures given: council 5.1 years. Decision 6008802
  3. Five years shownNot disputed10 June 2026 - appeal dismissed
    Greystones Chalkpit Lane, BETCHWORTH
    “It is common ground that Mole Valley District Council has a five-year housing land supply”
  4. Five years shownDisputed9 March 2026 - appeal dismissed
    Gadbrook Cottage, Little Abbots Farm, Snowerhill Road, Betchworth, Surrey
    “The Council can currently demonstrate a 5.1-year supply of housing, which includes a 20% buffer, and achieved 78% in the latest HDT published in 2024.”
    Figures given: council 5.1 years, inspector 5.1 years. Decision 6002245
  5. Five years shownNot disputed22 December 2025 - appeal dismissed
    Happy Paddocks Farm, Stan Hill, Charlwood, Surrey
    “The evidence before me demonstrates that the Council can demonstrate a five-year supply through the recent adoption of its Local Plan.”
  6. Five years shownDisputed28 November 2025 - appeal dismissed
    Hillside Farm, Cudworth Lane, Newdigate, Surrey
    “the Council can currently demonstrate a five year supply of deliverable housing sites in the Framework's terms.”
    Figures given: council 5 years. Decision 3367924
  7. Five years shownDisputed31 October 2025 - appeal allowed
    The Old Barley Mow, Old Reigate Road, BETCHWORTH
    “the policies of the MVLP should not be regarded as out of date because the plan was adopted less than five years ago. The proposal does not therefore satisfy paragraph 155(b) of the Framework.”
    Figures given: council 5.1 years, inspector 5.1 years. Decision 3369415
  8. Five years shownDisputed19 August 2025 - appeal dismissed
    Land adjacent to Robins Nest, Ifield Road, Charlwood, Horley
    “it sets out that it can demonstrate a housing land supply of 5 years. I have no substantive evidence to the contrary”
    Figures given: council 5 years. Decision 3361127

Showing the 8 most recent of 52 decisions in Mole Valley that dealt with land supply. Planther searches and reads all of them for a site.

Housing Delivery Test

The Housing Delivery Test compares the homes built in a council's area over three years with the number needed. Mole Valley scored 72% in the 2025 measurement, published on 17 August 2026. The consequence listed in the government's results is: Presumption in favour of sustainable development.

YearHomes neededHomes delivered
2022 to 2023338217
2023 to 2024338154
2024 to 2025338361

Source: Housing Delivery Test 2025 measurement. Every council's result: Housing Delivery Test results.

Local plan

The development plan is the Mole Valley Local Plan 2020-2039 (2024), South East Plan Policy NRM6: Thames Basin Heaths SPA (saved), Surrey Waste Local Plan 2019-2033 (2020), Surrey Minerals Plan Core Strategy (2011), Surrey Minerals Plan Primary Aggregates DPD (2011) and Aggregates Recycling Joint DPD (2013), adopted on 15 October 2024, covering 2020 to 2039. It replaced 3 earlier plans, including the Mole Valley Core Strategy (2009).

Four made plans (Ashtead, Bookham, Capel, Westcott, 2017). Westcott's replacement awaits referendum; Capel is reviewing its plan; Betchworth and Ockley have area applications under way.

Source: the council's local plan pages. Checked 2026-11-02 (2 weeks ago). Every council: where each local plan has got to.

Planning appeals

Since 2016, inspectors have decided 704 appeals against Mole Valley's decisions and allowed 221 of them (31%), against 31% across all councils. For major schemes, 12 of 27 were allowed (44%, against 50% across all councils).

YearDecidedAllowedShare allowed
20196219 (31%)
20205414 (26%)
20215721 (37%)
20224414 (32%)
20237518 (24%)
20246714 (21%)
20259831 (32%)
20267428 (38%)

Decided means allowed, dismissed or split, with a decision date; a split decision counts as decided but not allowed. From the Planning Inspectorate's published decisions.

Mole Valley's own pages

Land supply around Mole Valley

Arun: 3.23 yearsBarking and Dagenham: No current figure publishedBarnet: No current figure publishedBasildon: 2.05 yearsBasingstoke and Deane: 3.2 yearsBexley: 6.02 yearsBracknell Forest: 3.53 yearsBrent: No current figure publishedBrentwood: 4.53 yearsBrighton and Hove: No current figure publishedBromley: 1.93 yearsBuckinghamshire: 0.86 yearsCamden: 2.8 yearsCastle Point: 0.91 yearsChichester: 5.16 yearsCrawley: 5.4 yearsCroydon: 5.1 yearsDartford: 5.84 yearsEaling: 5 yearsEast Hampshire: 2.9 yearsElmbridge: 1 yearsEpsom and Ewell: Says it cannot show five yearsFareham: 2.99 yearsGravesham: 2.53 yearsGreenwich: 3.02 yearsGuildford: 2.98 yearsHackney: No current figure publishedHammersmith and Fulham: No current figure publishedHaringey: No current figure publishedHarrow: 5.2 yearsHart: 2.07 yearsHastings: 1.65 yearsHavant: 1.3 yearsHavering: 3 yearsHillingdon: 2.5 yearsHorsham: 1.7 yearsHounslow: No current figure publishedIslington: No current figure publishedKensington and Chelsea: 5 yearsKingston upon Thames: 1.48 yearsLambeth: 4.21 yearsLewes: 3.02 yearsLewisham: No current figure publishedCity of London: 7.7 yearsMaidstone: 4.5 yearsMedway: 3.1 yearsMerton: 5.2 yearsMid Sussex: Says it cannot show five yearsMole Valley: 5.3 yearsNewham: No current figure publishedPortsmouth: 2.4 yearsReading: 3.55 yearsRedbridge: Says it cannot show five yearsReigate and Banstead: 4.08 yearsRichmond upon Thames: 4.5 yearsRother: 3.04 yearsRunnymede: 2.89 yearsRushmoor: 4.74 yearsSevenoaks: 3.59 yearsSlough: No current figure publishedSouth Oxfordshire: 4.46 yearsSouthwark: No current figure publishedSpelthorne: 5.3 yearsSurrey Heath: 7.71 yearsSutton: No current figure publishedTandridge: 2.17 yearsThurrock: 1.02 yearsTonbridge and Malling: No current figure publishedTower Hamlets: No current figure publishedTunbridge Wells: 4.7 yearsWaltham Forest: 5.05 yearsWandsworth: 5.24 yearsWaverley: 1.28 yearsWealden: 3.65 yearsWest Berkshire: 5.7 yearsWestminster: 5.19 yearsWinchester: No current figure publishedWindsor and Maidenhead: 3.53 yearsWoking: 4.57 yearsWokingham: 2.5 yearsWorthing: 6.9 years
6 years or more5 to 6 years4 to 5 years, or says it cannot show fiveUnder 4 yearsNo current figure published

Each council's own latest figure. The whole country: land supply map of England.

About this page

Planther keeps track of every council's plan, land supply position and appeal record, and rebuilds this page every night from what it holds. Figures are the council's own unless they are marked as an inspector's. If something here is wrong, email hello@planther.co.uk and we will put it right.

See Planther at work in Mole Valley

Ask Planther about a site and it does the research: the council's position, the appeals that matter, and a first draft, each point with its source. Here it answers a question about Mole Valley from the figures on this page.

Book a demo

We will show you round Planther, then set you up with a trial so you can try it on your own work. We can usually have you, or your whole firm, up and running the same day.

Bringing a whole firm? We can work to your own contract and data processing agreement, and invoice you directly.